💼
Enterprise SaaS 产品技术与架构落后 2011 - 2024

联邦政府的薪酬系统灾难 (Phoenix Pay):一个用来发工资的新系统,为什么反而让几十万人领不到正确的工资?

把几十年的例外规则从旧系统搬到新系统,最难的是那些没人写下来的部分

联邦政府的薪酬系统灾难 (Phoenix Pay):巅峰期加拿大联邦政府用来替换运行数十年的老旧系统的统一薪酬平台,覆盖数十万公务员的工资发放,由外部承包商负责实施;终局是上线后数十万公务员遭遇工资错误,修复成本从数亿加元膨胀到数十亿加元,政府最终决定另建新系统取代它。

See the patterns
公开报道整理 待核查 Figures as of 2024 0 sources What do these mean?

How to read this bar

This bar states plainly what we know and what we have checked, so you can judge it yourself.

· Review status: “pending” means no editor has checked it against the sources yet; “checked” means key facts match the sources.

· Figures as of: the year the numbers are current to; later changes are out of scope.

· Sources: listed one by one at the bottom of the page. “Primary” means official filings, annual reports or regulator documents.

· Corrections: every change and its basis is published — nothing is edited silently.

Editorial policy → Editorial policy: the full inclusion rules, verification process, AI disclosure and correction promise.

No English translation for this case yet — showing the stored original.
Peak valuation

加拿大联邦政府用来替换运行数十年的老旧系统的统一薪酬平台,覆盖数十万公务员的工资发放,由外部承包商负责实施

Final cost

上线后数十万公务员遭遇工资错误,修复成本从数亿加元膨胀到数十亿加元,政府最终决定另建新系统取代它

Attribution votes

5,776 votes cast

Community output

1 plans · 1 insights

Sponsored
把你亲历的失败写进来

投稿会先进入待审,通过后才进入公开目录和站点地图。

Root Causes Consensus Poll

Vote for the primary fatal error that caused this enterprise to collapse.

产品技术

旧系统的隐性规则未被完整迁移

数十年积累的例外与人工处理逻辑丢失,计算错误成批出现

1,900 votes (33%)
组织管理

为满足周期压缩测试

大量规则未经验证即上线,错误直接落在工资单上

1,596 votes (28%)
资本财务

救火模式消耗资源

外包团队长期做手工修正,成本远超原预算且看不到终点

1,292 votes (22%)
战略

缺少与工会的前置沟通与并行验证

使用者与代表方未被纳入验证环节,问题在真实发薪时才暴露

988 votes (17%)